1 | <!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01 Transitional//EN"> |
---|
2 | <html> |
---|
3 | <head> |
---|
4 | <title>Smart Pointers</title> |
---|
5 | <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=iso-8859-1"> |
---|
6 | </head> |
---|
7 | <body bgcolor="#ffffff" text="#000000"> |
---|
8 | <h1><A href="../../index.htm"><img src="../../boost.png" alt="boost.png (6897 bytes)" align="middle" width="277" height="86" |
---|
9 | border="0"></A>Smart Pointers</h1> |
---|
10 | <p><a href="#Introduction">Introduction</a><br> |
---|
11 | <a href="#common_requirements">Common Requirements</a><br> |
---|
12 | <a href="#Exception_Safety">Exception Safety</a><br> |
---|
13 | <a href="#Exception-specifications">Exception-specifications</a><br> |
---|
14 | <a href="#History">History and Acknowledgements</a><br> |
---|
15 | <a href="#References">References</a></p> |
---|
16 | <h2><a name="Introduction">Introduction</a></h2> |
---|
17 | <p>Smart pointers are objects which store pointers to dynamically allocated (heap) |
---|
18 | objects. They behave much like built-in C++ pointers except that they |
---|
19 | automatically delete the object pointed to at the appropriate time. Smart |
---|
20 | pointers are particularly useful in the face of exceptions as they ensure |
---|
21 | proper destruction of dynamically allocated objects. They can also be used to |
---|
22 | keep track of dynamically allocated objects shared by multiple owners.</p> |
---|
23 | <p>Conceptually, smart pointers are seen as owning the object pointed to, and thus |
---|
24 | responsible for deletion of the object when it is no longer needed.</p> |
---|
25 | <p>The smart pointer library provides five smart pointer class templates:</p> |
---|
26 | <div align="left"> |
---|
27 | <table border="1" cellpadding="4" cellspacing="0"> |
---|
28 | <tr> |
---|
29 | <td><a href="scoped_ptr.htm"><b>scoped_ptr</b></a></td> |
---|
30 | <td><a href="../../boost/scoped_ptr.hpp"><boost/scoped_ptr.hpp></a></td> |
---|
31 | <td>Simple sole ownership of single objects. Noncopyable.</td> |
---|
32 | </tr> |
---|
33 | <tr> |
---|
34 | <td><a href="scoped_array.htm"><b>scoped_array</b></a></td> |
---|
35 | <td><a href="../../boost/scoped_array.hpp"><boost/scoped_array.hpp></a></td> |
---|
36 | <td>Simple sole ownership of arrays. Noncopyable.</td> |
---|
37 | </tr> |
---|
38 | <tr> |
---|
39 | <td><a href="shared_ptr.htm"><b>shared_ptr</b></a></td> |
---|
40 | <td><a href="../../boost/shared_ptr.hpp"><boost/shared_ptr.hpp></a></td> |
---|
41 | <td>Object ownership shared among multiple pointers</td> |
---|
42 | </tr> |
---|
43 | <tr> |
---|
44 | <td><a href="shared_array.htm"><b>shared_array</b></a></td> |
---|
45 | <td><a href="../../boost/shared_array.hpp"><boost/shared_array.hpp></a></td> |
---|
46 | <td>Array ownership shared among multiple pointers.</td> |
---|
47 | </tr> |
---|
48 | <tr> |
---|
49 | <td><a href="weak_ptr.htm"><b>weak_ptr</b></a></td> |
---|
50 | <td><a href="../../boost/weak_ptr.hpp"><boost/weak_ptr.hpp></a></td> |
---|
51 | <td>Non-owning observers of an object owned by <b>shared_ptr</b>.</td> |
---|
52 | </tr> |
---|
53 | <tr> |
---|
54 | <td><a href="intrusive_ptr.html"><b>intrusive_ptr</b></a></td> |
---|
55 | <td><a href="../../boost/intrusive_ptr.hpp"><boost/intrusive_ptr.hpp></a></td> |
---|
56 | <td>Shared ownership of objects with an embedded reference count.</td> |
---|
57 | </tr> |
---|
58 | </table> |
---|
59 | </div> |
---|
60 | <p>These templates are designed to complement the <b>std::auto_ptr</b> template.</p> |
---|
61 | <p>They are examples of the "resource acquisition is initialization" idiom |
---|
62 | described in Bjarne Stroustrup's "The C++ Programming Language", 3rd edition, |
---|
63 | Section 14.4, Resource Management.</p> |
---|
64 | <p>A test program, <a href="test/smart_ptr_test.cpp">smart_ptr_test.cpp</a>, is |
---|
65 | provided to verify correct operation.</p> |
---|
66 | <p>A page on <a href="compatibility.htm">compatibility</a> with older versions of |
---|
67 | the Boost smart pointer library describes some of the changes since earlier |
---|
68 | versions of the smart pointer implementation.</p> |
---|
69 | <p>A page on <a href="smarttests.htm">smart pointer timings</a> will be of interest |
---|
70 | to those curious about performance issues.</p> |
---|
71 | <P>A page on <A href="sp_techniques.html">smart pointer programming techniques</A> lists |
---|
72 | some advanced applications of <code>shared_ptr</code> and <code>weak_ptr</code>.</P> |
---|
73 | <h2><a name="common_requirements">Common Requirements</a></h2> |
---|
74 | <p>These smart pointer class templates have a template parameter, <b>T</b>, which |
---|
75 | specifies the type of the object pointed to by the smart pointer. The behavior |
---|
76 | of the smart pointer templates is undefined if the destructor or <b>operator delete</b> |
---|
77 | for objects of type <b>T</b> throw exceptions.</p> |
---|
78 | <p><b>T</b> may be an incomplete type at the point of smart pointer declaration. |
---|
79 | Unless otherwise specified, it is required that <b>T</b> be a complete type at |
---|
80 | points of smart pointer instantiation. Implementations are required to diagnose |
---|
81 | (treat as an error) all violations of this requirement, including deletion of |
---|
82 | an incomplete type. See the description of the <a href="../utility/utility.htm#checked_delete"> |
---|
83 | <b>checked_delete</b></a> function template.</p> |
---|
84 | <P>Note that <STRONG>shared_ptr</STRONG> does not have this restriction, as most of |
---|
85 | its member functions do not require <STRONG>T</STRONG> to be a complete type.</P> |
---|
86 | <h3>Rationale</h3> |
---|
87 | <p>The requirements on <b>T</b> are carefully crafted to maximize safety yet allow |
---|
88 | handle-body (also called pimpl) and similar idioms. In these idioms a smart |
---|
89 | pointer may appear in translation units where <b>T</b> is an incomplete type. |
---|
90 | This separates interface from implementation and hides implementation from |
---|
91 | translation units which merely use the interface. Examples described in the |
---|
92 | documentation for specific smart pointers illustrate use of smart pointers in |
---|
93 | these idioms.</p> |
---|
94 | <p>Note that <b>scoped_ptr</b> requires that <b>T</b> be a complete type at |
---|
95 | destruction time, but <b>shared_ptr</b> does not.</p> |
---|
96 | <h2><a name="Exception_Safety">Exception Safety</a></h2> |
---|
97 | <p>Several functions in these smart pointer classes are specified as having "no |
---|
98 | effect" or "no effect except such-and-such" if an exception is thrown. This |
---|
99 | means that when an exception is thrown by an object of one of these classes, |
---|
100 | the entire program state remains the same as it was prior to the function call |
---|
101 | which resulted in the exception being thrown. This amounts to a guarantee that |
---|
102 | there are no detectable side effects. Other functions never throw exceptions. |
---|
103 | The only exception ever thrown by functions which do throw (assuming <b>T</b> meets |
---|
104 | the <a href="#common_requirements">common requirements</a>) is <b>std::bad_alloc</b>, |
---|
105 | and that is thrown only by functions which are explicitly documented as |
---|
106 | possibly throwing <b>std::bad_alloc</b>.</p> |
---|
107 | <h2><a name="Exception-specifications">Exception-specifications</a></h2> |
---|
108 | <p>Exception-specifications are not used; see <a href="../../more/lib_guide.htm#Exception-specification"> |
---|
109 | exception-specification rationale</a>.</p> |
---|
110 | <p>All the smart pointer templates contain member functions which can never throw |
---|
111 | exceptions, because they neither throw exceptions themselves nor call other |
---|
112 | functions which may throw exceptions. These members are indicated by a comment: <code> |
---|
113 | // never throws</code>. |
---|
114 | </p> |
---|
115 | <p>Functions which destroy objects of the pointed to type are prohibited from |
---|
116 | throwing exceptions by the <a href="#common_requirements">common requirements</a>.</p> |
---|
117 | <h2><a name="History">History</a> and Acknowledgements</h2> |
---|
118 | <p>January 2002. Peter Dimov reworked all four classes, adding features, fixing |
---|
119 | bugs, and splitting them into four separate headers, and added <b>weak_ptr</b>. |
---|
120 | See the <a href="compatibility.htm">compatibility</a> page for a summary of the |
---|
121 | changes.</p> |
---|
122 | <p>May 2001. Vladimir Prus suggested requiring a complete type on destruction. |
---|
123 | Refinement evolved in discussions including Dave Abrahams, Greg Colvin, Beman |
---|
124 | Dawes, Rainer Deyke, Peter Dimov, John Maddock, Vladimir Prus, Shankar Sai, and |
---|
125 | others.</p> |
---|
126 | <p>November 1999. Darin Adler provided <b>operator ==</b>, <b>operator !=</b>, and <b>std::swap</b> |
---|
127 | and <b>std::less</b> specializations for shared types.</p> |
---|
128 | <p>September 1999. Luis Coelho provided <b>shared_ptr::swap</b> and <b>shared_array::swap</b></p> |
---|
129 | <p>May 1999. In April and May, 1999, Valentin Bonnard and David Abrahams made a |
---|
130 | number of suggestions resulting in numerous improvements.</p> |
---|
131 | <p>October 1998. Beman Dawes proposed reviving the original semantics under the |
---|
132 | names <b>safe_ptr</b> and <b>counted_ptr</b>, meeting of Per Andersson, Matt |
---|
133 | Austern, Greg Colvin, Sean Corfield, Pete Becker, Nico Josuttis, Dietmar Kühl, |
---|
134 | Nathan Myers, Chichiang Wan and Judy Ward. During the discussion, the four new |
---|
135 | class names were finalized, it was decided that there was no need to exactly |
---|
136 | follow the <b>std::auto_ptr</b> interface, and various function signatures and |
---|
137 | semantics were finalized.</p> |
---|
138 | <p>Over the next three months, several implementations were considered for <b>shared_ptr</b>, |
---|
139 | and discussed on the <a href="http://www.boost.org">boost.org</a> mailing list. |
---|
140 | The implementation questions revolved around the reference count which must be |
---|
141 | kept, either attached to the pointed to object, or detached elsewhere. Each of |
---|
142 | those variants have themselves two major variants: |
---|
143 | <ul> |
---|
144 | <li> |
---|
145 | Direct detached: the shared_ptr contains a pointer to the object, and a pointer |
---|
146 | to the count. |
---|
147 | <li> |
---|
148 | Indirect detached: the shared_ptr contains a pointer to a helper object, which |
---|
149 | in turn contains a pointer to the object and the count. |
---|
150 | <li> |
---|
151 | Embedded attached: the count is a member of the object pointed to. |
---|
152 | <li> |
---|
153 | Placement attached: the count is attached via operator new manipulations.</li> |
---|
154 | </ul> |
---|
155 | <p>Each implementation technique has advantages and disadvantages. We went so far |
---|
156 | as to run various timings of the direct and indirect approaches, and found that |
---|
157 | at least on Intel Pentium chips there was very little measurable difference. |
---|
158 | Kevlin Henney provided a paper he wrote on "Counted Body Techniques." Dietmar |
---|
159 | Kühl suggested an elegant partial template specialization technique to allow |
---|
160 | users to choose which implementation they preferred, and that was also |
---|
161 | experimented with.</p> |
---|
162 | <p>But Greg Colvin and Jerry Schwarz argued that "parameterization will discourage |
---|
163 | users", and in the end we choose to supply only the direct implementation.</p> |
---|
164 | <p>Summer, 1994. Greg Colvin proposed to the C++ Standards Committee classes named <b>auto_ptr</b> |
---|
165 | and <b>counted_ptr</b> which were very similar to what we now call <b>scoped_ptr</b> |
---|
166 | and <b>shared_ptr</b>. <a href="#Col-94">[Col-94]</a> In one of the very few |
---|
167 | cases where the Library Working Group's recommendations were not followed by |
---|
168 | the full committee, <b>counted_ptr</b> was rejected and surprising |
---|
169 | transfer-of-ownership semantics were added to <b>auto_ptr</b>.</p> |
---|
170 | <h2><a name="References">References</a></h2> |
---|
171 | <p>[<a name="Col-94">Col-94</a>] Gregory Colvin, <a href="http://std.dkuug.dk/jtc1/sc22/wg21/docs/papers/1994/N0555.pdf"> |
---|
172 | Exception Safe Smart Pointers</a>, C++ committee document 94-168/N0555, |
---|
173 | July, 1994.</p> |
---|
174 | <p>[<a name="E&D-94">E&D-94</a>] John R. Ellis & David L. Detlefs, <a href="http://www.usenix.org/publications/library/proceedings/c++94/full_papers/ellis.a"> |
---|
175 | Safe, Efficient Garbage Collection for C++</a>, Usenix Proceedings, |
---|
176 | February, 1994. This paper includes an extensive discussion of weak pointers |
---|
177 | and an extensive bibliography.</p> |
---|
178 | <hr> |
---|
179 | <p>$Date: 2005/09/25 21:54:19 $</p> |
---|
180 | <p>Copyright 1999 Greg Colvin and Beman Dawes. Copyright 2002 Darin Adler. |
---|
181 | Permission to copy, use, modify, sell and distribute this document is granted |
---|
182 | provided this copyright notice appears in all copies. This document is provided |
---|
183 | "as is" without express or implied warranty, and with no claim as to its |
---|
184 | suitability for any purpose.</p> |
---|
185 | </body> |
---|
186 | </html> |
---|